Active
$497,000
Est. $3,133/mo

4161 Butler Ave, Sarasota, FL, 34234

$230/sqft·Newtown Farms

4 bd3 ba2,158 sqftSingle Family
Listed by PREFERRED SHORE LLC· Last updated · MLS# A4701656

Ask anything about this home

Pricing, comps, HOA, the neighborhood. Answers before you fill out anything.

Est. monthly payment
$3,133/mo
Down payment (20%)
$99,400
Property taxes
$293/mo
Rate assumed
6.8% · 30 yr
View full breakdown

At a glance

Single family
Built 1956
0.58 acres
Lot size
2,158 sqft
Living area

About this home

Primary Bedroom Main FloorWalk-in Closet(s)French DoorsGardenLightingRangeRange HoodRefrigerator

4161 Butler Ave is a 1956-built home in Newtown Farms, Sarasota. Inside you'll find 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and 2,158 square feet of living space. Listed at $497,000 (about $230/sqft), 6 days on market. Flood zone X - outside the FEMA high-risk areas, which keeps insurance manageable.

From the listing

Don't miss this exceptional opportunity to own a beautifully located property just minutes from Downtown Sarasota! Situated on a spacious OVER 25,000± square-foot lot, this 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers endless possibilities with no HOA restrictions. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, investment property, or a home with room to expand, this property provides the flexibility you've been searching for. The oversized lot offers ample space for a pool, RV, boat, workshop, guest house (subject to local regulations), or future additions. P

The essentials

Built
1956
Price / sqft
$230
On market
43 days
Annual tax
$3,513
Flood zone
X · Low risk
Lot
25,349 sqft
Type
Single Family Residence

Location

4161 Butler Ave
Sarasota, FL, 34234·34234 - Sarasota
Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1956
Lot
25,349 sqft
Cooling
Central Air
Heating
Central
Parking
-
Days on Market
43
Primary Bedroom Main Floor
Walk-in Closet(s)
French Doors
Garden
Lighting
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
Flood Zone X

Annual Tax (2025)

$3,513

Parcel #

0026090009

Taxes reflect the most recent assessment in the MLS feed. Actual tax owed can vary, so confirm with the county property appraiser before closing.

Subdivision

Newtown Farms

County

Sarasota

MLS Area

34234 - Sarasota

Lot Size

25,349 sqft

Date
Event
Price
7/30/2026
Listed for sale
Source: Stellar MLS #A4701656
$497,000
$230/sqft
Est. monthly payment$3,133/mo
Principal & interest$2,592
Property taxes$293
Insurance$249
Down payment20% · $99,400
Interest rate6.80%
Loan term

Not sure what you can afford?

Put in your household income and we will tell you where this payment sits.

Property taxes are this home's actual annual bill from the MLS, divided by twelve. Insurance estimated at 0.60%. Rate defaults to 6.8% on a 30-year fixed. Tap a pencil to use your own numbers. Estimates only, not a loan quote.

Offer Insights

Choose an offer strength

List price: $497,000
$480,000 – $497,000
96.7% – 100% of listTops out right at the list price
80% of listList price
33 of the last 63 home closings in 34234 landed at this number or higher (52%). The median one sat 67 days before it went under contract, and this one is on day 43.

Sample: 63 closed home sales in 34234 over the last 8 months, Stellar MLS. A starting point, not a guarantee.

Talk through an offer with our team

Keep exploring Tampa Bay

Pick up where you left off, or see what else is out there.

Homes in SarasotaNew constructionBrowse all listingsWhat's my home worth?Recently soldSchedule a tour